| First Quarter |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Mia | Ind |
| Mia | | | Dan Carpenter kicks off to the Ind0. Tom Zbikowski return for 34 yards to Ind30. Tackled by Jonathan Freeny. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind30 | Andrew Luck pass to the middle to Donnie Avery for 16 yards to the Ind46. Tackled by Nolan Carroll. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind46 | Vick Ballard rush up the middle for 1 yard to the Ind47. Tackled by Paul Soliai. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&9 | Ind47 | Vick Ballard rush to the left for a loss of 3 yards to the Ind44. Tackled by Karlos Dansby and Jared Odrick. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&12 | Ind44 | Andrew Luck pass to the left to Dwayne Allen for 22 yards to the Mia34. Tackled by Karlos Dansby. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Mia34 | Penalty: Holding on Indianapolis (Joe Reitz) -10 yards. | | |
| Ind | 1st&20 | Mia44 | Andrew Luck pass to the left to Donald Brown for 7 yards to the Mia37. Tackled by Koa Misi. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&13 | Mia37 | Andrew Luck pass to the middle to T.Y. Hilton for 12 yards to the Mia25. Tackled by Reshad Jones. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&1 | Mia25 | Delone Carter rush up the middle for no gain to the Mia25. Tackled by Kevin Burnett and Karlos Dansby. | | |
| Ind | 4th&1 | Mia25 | Penalty: Delay of Game on Indianapolis (Adam Vinatieri) -5 yards. | | |
| Ind | 4th&6 | Mia30 | 48 yard field goal attempt by Adam Vinatieri is NO GOOD. Holder: Pat McAfee. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia39 | Reggie Bush rush to the right for 1 yard to the Mia40. Tackled by Fili Moala and Kavell Conner. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&9 | Mia40 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the left to Davone Bess for 14 yards to the Ind46. Tackled by Cassius Vaughn. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Ind46 | Reggie Bush rush to the right for 3 yards to the Ind43. Tackled by Robert Mathis. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&7 | Ind43 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the right intended for Marlon Moore. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&7 | Ind43 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the left to Brian Hartline for 13 yards to the Ind30. Tackled by Cassius Vaughn and Tom Zbikowski. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Ind30 | Reggie Bush rush to the right for no gain to the Ind30. Tackled by Justin Hickman and Drake Nevis. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&10 | Ind30 | Penalty: Offside on Indianapolis (Dwight Freeney) 5 yards. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&5 | Ind25 | Daniel Thomas rush to the left for 6 yards to the Ind19. Tackled by Cassius Vaughn and Antoine Bethea. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Ind19 | Ryan Tannehill sacked at Ind28 for a loss of 9 yards by Robert Mathis. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&19 | Ind28 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the right intended for Anthony Fasano. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&19 | Ind28 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the middle to Davone Bess for 9 yards to the Ind19. Tackled by Antoine Bethea. | | |
| Mia | 4th&10 | Ind19 | Dan Carpenter 37 yard field goal attempt is GOOD. Holder: Brandon Fields. | | |
| Mia | | | Drive Stats: 11 plays, 42 yards, 5min 19sec | 3 | 0 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Mia | Ind |
| Mia | | | Dan Carpenter kicks off to the Ind0. Touchback. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind20 | Andrew Luck pass to the right to Reggie Wayne for 8 yards to the Ind28. Tackled by Jimmy Wilson and Sean Smith. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&2 | Ind28 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the left intended for Donnie Avery defensed by Jimmy Wilson. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&2 | Ind28 | Andrew Luck pass to the left to Reggie Wayne for 9 yards to the Ind37. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind37 | Vick Ballard rush to the left for a loss of 4 yards to the Ind33. Tackled by Reshad Jones. FUMBLE, recovered by Ind (Vick Ballard). | | |
| Ind | 2nd&14 | Ind33 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the left intended for Donnie Avery defensed by Nolan Carroll. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&14 | Ind33 | Andrew Luck pass to the right to T.Y. Hilton for 25 yards to the Mia42. Tackled by Chris Clemons. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Mia42 | Penalty: Pass Interference on Miami (Koa Misi) 32 yards. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Mia10 | T.Y. Hilton rush to the right for 1 yard to the Mia9. Tackled by Cameron Wake. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&9 | Mia9 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the left intended for T.Y. Hilton. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&9 | Mia9 | Andrew Luck pass to the right to Reggie Wayne for 9 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. | | |
| Ind | | | Adam Vinatieri extra point is good. | | |
| Ind | | | Drive Stats: 9 plays, 80 yards, 3min 28sec | 3 | 7 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Mia | Ind |
| Ind | | | Pat McAfee kicks off to the Mia0. Touchback. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia20 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the right to Brian Hartline for 35 yards to the Ind45. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Ind45 | Indianapolis Colts timeout. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Ind45 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the right to Brian Hartline for 10 yards to the Ind35. Tackled by Jerraud Powers. | | |
| |
| Second Quarter |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Mia | Ind |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Ind35 | Reggie Bush rush up the middle for 2 yards to the Ind33. Tackled by Antonio Johnson. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&8 | Ind33 | Penalty: False Start on Miami (Jake Long) -5 yards. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&13 | Ind38 | Penalty: Illegal Contact on Indianapolis (Cassius Vaughn) 5 yards. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Ind33 | Lamar Miller rush to the right for 7 yards to the Ind26. Tackled by Pat Angerer. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&3 | Ind26 | Penalty: Illegal Shift on Miami (Davone Bess) -5 yards. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&8 | Ind31 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the right to Charles Clay for 31 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. | | |
| Mia | | | Dan Carpenter extra point is good. | | |
| Mia | | | Drive Stats: 5 plays, 80 yards, 2min 22sec | 10 | 7 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Mia | Ind |
| Mia | | | Dan Carpenter kicks off to the Ind0. Touchback. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind20 | Andrew Luck pass to the right to Donnie Avery for 48 yards to the Mia32. Tackled by Sean Smith. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Mia32 | Delone Carter rush up the middle for 3 yards to the Mia29. Tackled by Derrick Shelby. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&7 | Mia29 | Delone Carter rush to the left for 4 yards to the Mia25. Tackled by Karlos Dansby. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&3 | Mia25 | Andrew Luck pass to the right to Vick Ballard for 14 yards to the Mia11. Tackled by Nolan Carroll. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Mia11 | Penalty: Illegal Plyr Downfld on Indianapolis (Samson Satele) -5 yards. | | |
| Ind | 1st&15 | Mia16 | Andrew Luck pass to the left to T.Y. Hilton for 2 yards to the Mia14. Tackled by Jared Odrick. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&13 | Mia14 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the right intended for T.Y. Hilton defensed by Nolan Carroll. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&13 | Mia14 | Andrew Luck pass to the left to Vick Ballard for 9 yards to the Mia5. Tackled by Nolan Carroll. | | |
| Ind | 4th&4 | Mia5 | Adam Vinatieri 23 yard field goal attempt is GOOD. Holder: Pat McAfee. | | |
| Ind | | | Drive Stats: 8 plays, 75 yards, 3min 48sec | 10 | 10 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Mia | Ind |
| Ind | | | Pat McAfee kicks off to the Mia0. Marcus Thigpen return for 26 yards to Mia20. Tackled by Darius Butler. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia20 | Ryan Tannehill sacked at Mia20 for no gain by Dwight Freeney. FUMBLE, recovered by Mia (Jake Long) and advanced for 2 yards. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&8 | Mia22 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the right intended for Brian Hartline. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&8 | Mia22 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the right to Reggie Bush for 19 yards to the Mia41. Tackled by Antoine Bethea. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia41 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the right to Daniel Thomas for 11 yards to the Ind48. Tackled by Ricardo Mathews. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Ind48 | Daniel Thomas rush to the left for 20 yards to the Ind28. Tackled by Cassius Vaughn. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Ind28 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the right to Brian Hartline for 7 yards to the Ind21. Tackled by Jerraud Powers. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&3 | Ind21 | Daniel Thomas rush up the middle for 2 yards to the Ind19. Tackled by Kavell Conner and Antoine Bethea. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&1 | Ind19 | Daniel Thomas rush up the middle for 1 yard to the Ind18. Tackled by Cory Redding and Mario Harvey. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Ind18 | Reggie Bush rush to the left for 18 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. Penalty: Unnecessary Roughness on Indianapolis (Cassius Vaughn) 15 yards. | | |
| Mia | | | Dan Carpenter extra point is good. | | |
| Mia | | | Drive Stats: 9 plays, 80 yards, 4min 30sec | 17 | 10 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Mia | Ind |
| Mia | | | Dan Carpenter kicks off to the Ind0. Touchback. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind20 | Andrew Luck pass to the middle to Reggie Wayne for 21 yards to the Ind41. Tackled by Nolan Carroll. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind41 | Vick Ballard rush to the left for 7 yards to the Ind48. Tackled by Sean Smith. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&3 | Ind48 | Andrew Luck pass to the right to Donnie Avery for 8 yards to the Mia44. Tackled by Nolan Carroll. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Mia44 | Vick Ballard rush up the middle for 10 yards to the Mia34. Tackled by Reshad Jones. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Mia34 | Vick Ballard rush up the middle for a loss of 2 yards to the Mia36. Tackled by Paul Soliai. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&12 | Mia36 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the left intended for Vick Ballard. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&12 | Mia36 | Miami Dolphins timeout. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&12 | Mia36 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the right intended for LaVon Brazill. | | |
| Ind | 4th&12 | Mia36 | Adam Vinatieri 54 yard field goal attempt is BLOCKED by Olivier Vernon. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia44 | Reggie Bush rush up the middle for 2 yards to the Mia46. Tackled by Moise Fokou. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&8 | Mia46 | Two Minute Warning. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&8 | Mia46 | Penalty: False Start on Miami (Mike Pouncey) -7 yards. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&15 | Mia39 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the middle to Davone Bess for 9 yards to the Mia48. Tackled by Antoine Bethea. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&6 | Mia48 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the right intended for Brian Hartline. | | |
| Mia | 4th&6 | Mia48 | Brandon Fields punts for 44 yards to Ind8. T.Y. Hilton return for 5 yards to Ind13. Tackled by Jason Trusnik. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Mia | Ind |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind13 | Andrew Luck pass to the right to Dwayne Allen for 12 yards to the Ind25. Tackled by Cameron Wake. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind25 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the middle intended for T.Y. Hilton. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&10 | Ind25 | Andrew Luck pass to the left to Reggie Wayne for 13 yards to the Ind38. Tackled by Jimmy Wilson. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind38 | Indianapolis Colts timeout. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind38 | Andrew Luck pass to the right to Reggie Wayne for 12 yards to the Ind50. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind50 | Andrew Luck rush to the right for 5 yards to the Mia45. Tackled by Karlos Dansby. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&5 | Mia45 | Andrew Luck pass to the left to LaVon Brazill for 6 yards to the Mia39. Tackled by Nolan Carroll. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Mia39 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the right intended for T.Y. Hilton. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&10 | Mia39 | Penalty: Holding on Indianapolis (Winston Justice) -10 yards. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&20 | Mia49 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the left intended for Vick Ballard. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&20 | Mia49 | Andrew Luck pass to the right to T.Y. Hilton for 20 yards to the Mia29. Tackled by R.J. Stanford. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Mia29 | Indianapolis Colts timeout. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Mia29 | Miami Dolphins timeout. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Mia29 | Adam Vinatieri 47 yard field goal attempt is GOOD. Holder: Pat McAfee. | | |
| Ind | | | Drive Stats: 10 plays, 58 yards, 1min 7sec | 17 | 13 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Mia | Ind |
| Ind | | | Pat McAfee kicks off to the Mia0. Touchback. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia20 | Ryan Tannehill rush up the middle for a loss of 1 yard to the Mia19. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Mia | Ind |
| |
| Third Quarter |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Mia | Ind |
| Ind | | | Pat McAfee kicks off to the Mia0. Touchback. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia20 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the right to Brian Hartline for 8 yards to the Mia28. Tackled by Jerraud Powers and Antoine Bethea. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&2 | Mia28 | Reggie Bush rush up the middle for 3 yards to the Mia31. Tackled by Jerrell Freeman and Fili Moala. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia31 | Reggie Bush rush up the middle for 4 yards to the Mia35. Tackled by Kavell Conner. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&6 | Mia35 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the right intended for Brian Hartline. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&6 | Mia35 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the middle intended for Davone Bess. | | |
| Mia | 4th&6 | Mia35 | Brandon Fields punts for 59 yards to Ind6. T.Y. Hilton return for 14 yards to Ind20. Tackled by Jason Trusnik. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Mia | Ind |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind20 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the right intended for Reggie Wayne. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&10 | Ind20 | Delone Carter rush to the left for 9 yards to the Ind29. Tackled by Olivier Vernon. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&1 | Ind29 | Indianapolis Colts timeout. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&1 | Ind29 | Andrew Luck pass to the left to Donnie Avery for 14 yards to the Ind43. Tackled by Nolan Carroll. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind43 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the left intended for Vick Ballard. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&10 | Ind43 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the right intended for LaVon Brazill. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&10 | Ind43 | Andrew Luck pass to the left to Donnie Avery for 22 yards to the Mia35. Tackled by Chris Clemons. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Mia35 | Delone Carter rush to the left for 1 yard to the Mia34. Tackled by Nolan Carroll. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&9 | Mia34 | Andrew Luck sacked at Mia48 for a loss of 14 yards by Cameron Wake. FUMBLE, recovered by Ind (Dwayne Allen). | | |
| Ind | 3rd&25 | Ind50 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the left intended for Donnie Avery defensed by Nolan Carroll. | | |
| Ind | 4th&25 | Ind50 | Pat McAfee punts for 40 yards to Mia10. No return. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Mia | Ind |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia10 | Reggie Bush rush up the middle for a loss of 1 yard to the Mia9. Tackled by Jerrell Freeman. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&11 | Mia9 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the right to Brian Hartline for 12 yards to the Mia21. Tackled by Pat Angerer and Jerry Hughes. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia21 | Penalty: Holding on Miami (Anthony Fasano) -10 yards. | | |
| Mia | 1st&20 | Mia11 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the left intended for Anthony Fasano. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&20 | Mia11 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the right to Reggie Bush for 6 yards to the Mia17. Tackled by Moise Fokou. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&14 | Mia17 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the left to Davone Bess for 6 yards to the Mia23. Tackled by Darius Butler and Drake Nevis. | | |
| Mia | 4th&8 | Mia23 | Brandon Fields punts for 60 yards to Ind17. T.Y. Hilton return for 1 yard to Ind18. Tackled by Marlon Moore. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Mia | Ind |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind18 | Vick Ballard rush to the left for 4 yards to the Ind22. Tackled by Chris Clemons. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&6 | Ind22 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the left intended for Weslye Saunders. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&6 | Ind22 | Andrew Luck pass to the left to Vick Ballard for 15 yards to the Ind37. Tackled by Kevin Burnett. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind37 | Vick Ballard rush to the right for 4 yards to the Ind41. Tackled by Kevin Burnett. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&6 | Ind41 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the left intended for Dwayne Allen defensed by Karlos Dansby. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&6 | Ind41 | Penalty: Pass Interference on Indianapolis (Dwayne Allen) -10 yards. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&16 | Ind31 | Andrew Luck pass to the left to LaVon Brazill for 19 yards to the Ind50. Tackled by Jimmy Wilson. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind50 | Delone Carter rush up the middle for 9 yards to the Mia41. Tackled by Chris Clemons and Kevin Burnett. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&1 | Mia41 | Delone Carter rush up the middle for 5 yards to the Mia36. Tackled by Kheeston Randall. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Mia36 | Andrew Luck pass to the right to T.Y. Hilton for 36 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. | | |
| Ind | | | Adam Vinatieri extra point is good. | | |
| Ind | | | Drive Stats: 9 plays, 82 yards, 4min 27sec | 17 | 20 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Mia | Ind |
| Ind | | | Pat McAfee kicks off to the Mia0. Marcus Thigpen return for 27 yards to Mia20. Tackled by Sergio Brown. Penalty: Illegal Block on Indianapolis (Joe Lefeged) 15 yards. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia35 | Daniel Thomas rush to the left for 3 yards to the Mia38. Tackled by Kavell Conner. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&7 | Mia38 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the right to Brian Hartline for 15 yards to the Ind47. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Ind47 | Daniel Thomas rush up the middle for 5 yards to the Ind42. Tackled by Cory Redding and Fili Moala. | | |
| |
| Fourth Quarter |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Mia | Ind |
| Mia | 2nd&5 | Ind42 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the left intended for Anthony Fasano defensed by Kavell Conner. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&5 | Ind42 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the left to Davone Bess for 13 yards to the Ind29. Tackled by Cassius Vaughn. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Ind29 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the left to Davone Bess for 16 yards to the Ind13. Tackled by Darius Butler. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Ind13 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the right intended for Jorvorskie Lane. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&10 | Ind13 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the left intended for Jabar Gaffney. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&10 | Ind13 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the left intended for Daniel Thomas. | | |
| Mia | 4th&10 | Ind13 | Dan Carpenter 31 yard field goal attempt is GOOD. Holder: Brandon Fields. | | |
| Mia | | | Drive Stats: 10 plays, 52 yards, 3min 37sec | 20 | 20 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Mia | Ind |
| Mia | | | Dan Carpenter kicks off to the Ind0. Tom Zbikowski return for 18 yards to Ind12. Tackled by Jason Trusnik and Olivier Vernon. Penalty: Illegal Wedge on Indianapolis (Martin Tevaseu) -6 yards. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind6 | Andrew Luck pass to the right to Dwayne Allen for a loss of 1 yard to the Ind5. Tackled by Nolan Carroll. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&11 | Ind5 | Delone Carter rush up the middle for no gain to the Ind5. Tackled by Kevin Burnett. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&11 | Ind5 | Andrew Luck pass to the right to Dwayne Allen for 20 yards to the Ind25. Tackled by Chris Clemons and Karlos Dansby. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind25 | Vick Ballard rush to the left for 3 yards to the Ind28. Tackled by Karlos Dansby. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&7 | Ind28 | Andrew Luck pass to the middle to Dwayne Allen for 20 yards to the Ind48. Tackled by Chris Clemons. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind48 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the right intended for LaVon Brazill. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&10 | Ind48 | Andrew Luck pass to the right to T.Y. Hilton for 7 yards to the Mia45. Tackled by Sean Smith. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&3 | Mia45 | Andrew Luck pass to the left to Reggie Wayne for 6 yards to the Mia39. Tackled by Sean Smith. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Mia39 | Vick Ballard rush up the middle for 10 yards to the Mia29. Tackled by Reshad Jones. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Mia29 | Vick Ballard rush up the middle for 2 yards to the Mia27. Tackled by Karlos Dansby. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&8 | Mia27 | Andrew Luck pass to the middle to Dwayne Allen for 2 yards to the Mia25. Tackled by Kevin Burnett. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&6 | Mia25 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the left intended for T.Y. Hilton defensed by Reshad Jones. | | |
| Ind | 4th&6 | Mia25 | Adam Vinatieri 43 yard field goal attempt is GOOD. Holder: Pat McAfee. | | |
| Ind | | | Drive Stats: 13 plays, 69 yards, 7min 14sec | 20 | 23 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Mia | Ind |
| Ind | | | Pat McAfee kicks off to the Mia0. Marcus Thigpen return for 26 yards to Mia21. Tackled by Darius Butler. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia21 | Reggie Bush rush to the left for 9 yards to the Mia30. Tackled by Tom Zbikowski. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&1 | Mia30 | Penalty: Too Many Men on Field on Indianapolis 5 yards. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia35 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the left to Jabar Gaffney for 9 yards to the Mia44. Tackled by Cassius Vaughn. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&1 | Mia44 | Penalty: False Start on Miami (Richie Incognito) -5 yards. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&6 | Mia39 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the right intended for Brian Hartline defensed by Darius Butler. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&6 | Mia39 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the right intended for Davone Bess. | | |
| Mia | 4th&6 | Mia39 | Brandon Fields punts for 50 yards to Ind11. T.Y. Hilton return for 9 yards to Ind20. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Mia | Ind |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind20 | Vick Ballard rush to the left for 3 yards to the Ind23. Tackled by Cameron Wake. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&7 | Ind23 | Miami Dolphins timeout. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&7 | Ind23 | Vick Ballard rush to the left for 3 yards to the Ind26. Tackled by Karlos Dansby. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&4 | Ind26 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the left intended for Reggie Wayne defensed by Sean Smith. | | |
| Ind | 4th&4 | Ind26 | Pat McAfee punts for 59 yards to Mia15. Marcus Thigpen return for 12 yards to Mia27. Tackled by Pat McAfee. Penalty: Holding on Miami (Marlon Moore) -10 yards. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Mia | Ind |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia17 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the right to Anthony Fasano for 8 yards to the Mia25. Tackled by Moise Fokou. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&2 | Mia25 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the right to Brian Hartline for 7 yards to the Mia32. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia32 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the left to Jabar Gaffney for 18 yards to the Mia50. Tackled by Tom Zbikowski. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia50 | Two Minute Warning. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia50 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the left intended for Reggie Bush. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&10 | Mia50 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the right intended for Daniel Thomas. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&10 | Mia50 | Penalty: False Start on Miami (Mike Pouncey) -5 yards. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&15 | Mia45 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the right intended for Davone Bess. | | |
| Mia | 4th&15 | Mia45 | Miami Dolphins timeout. | | |
| Mia | 4th&15 | Mia45 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the left to Daniel Thomas for 14 yards to the Ind41. Tackled by Moise Fokou. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind41 | Vick Ballard rush to the left for 1 yard to the Ind42. Tackled by Jared Odrick. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&9 | Ind42 | Miami Dolphins timeout. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&9 | Ind42 | Vick Ballard rush up the middle for 2 yards to the Ind44. Tackled by Paul Soliai. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&7 | Ind44 | Indianapolis Colts timeout. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&7 | Ind44 | Vick Ballard rush to the left for 19 yards to the Mia37. Tackled by Jason Trusnik. | | |