| First Quarter |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Pit | | | Shaun Suisham kicks off to the Cle0. Touchback. | | |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Cle20 | Brandon Weeden pass to the right to Josh Gordon for 26 yards to the Cle46. Tackled by Ike Taylor. | | |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Cle46 | Trent Richardson rush to the left for 3 yards to the Cle49. Tackled by Larry Foote and Casey Hampton. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&7 | Cle49 | Brandon Weeden incomplete pass to the left intended for Travis Benjamin. | | |
| Cle | 3rd&7 | Cle49 | Brandon Weeden pass intended for Greg Little INTERCEPTED by Lawrence Timmons defensed by Brett Keisel and returned for 53 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Pit | | | Shaun Suisham extra point is good. | | |
| Pit | | | Drive Stats: 0 plays, 0 yards, 0sec | 7 | 0 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Pit | | | Shaun Suisham kicks off to the Cle0. Touchback. | | |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Cle20 | Brandon Weeden sacked at Cle12 for a loss of 8 yards by James Harrison. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&18 | Cle12 | Trent Richardson rush to the right for 2 yards to the Cle14. Tackled by Lawrence Timmons and Larry Foote. | | |
| Cle | 3rd&16 | Cle14 | Brandon Weeden incomplete pass to the left intended for Josh Gordon. | | |
| Cle | 4th&16 | Cle14 | Reggie Hodges punts for 45 yards to Pit41. No return. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Pit41 | Rashard Mendenhall rush to the right for 2 yards to the Pit43. Tackled by Frostee Rucker. | | |
| Pit | 2nd&8 | Pit43 | Rashard Mendenhall rush to the left for 3 yards to the Pit46. Tackled by Ahtyba Rubin and Usama Young. FUMBLE, recovered by Cle (Usama Young) and returned for 2 yards. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Pit44 | Trent Richardson rush to the right for 6 yards to the Pit38. Tackled by Ryan Clark. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&4 | Pit38 | Trent Richardson rush to the left for 7 yards to the Pit31. Tackled by Lawrence Timmons. | | |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Pit31 | Montario Hardesty rush to the left for 13 yards to the Pit18. Tackled by Ryan Clark and Will Allen. | | |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Pit18 | Montario Hardesty rush to the right for 1 yard to the Pit17. Tackled by Cameron Heyward. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&9 | Pit17 | Brandon Weeden incomplete pass to the right intended for Josh Gordon. | | |
| Cle | 3rd&9 | Pit17 | Brandon Weeden pass to the right to Mohamed Massaquoi for 6 yards to the Pit11. Tackled by Cortez Allen. | | |
| Cle | 4th&3 | Pit11 | Phil Dawson 28 yard field goal attempt is GOOD. Holder: Reggie Hodges. | | |
| Cle | | | Drive Stats: 7 plays, 33 yards, 3min 13sec | 7 | 3 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Cle | | | Phil Dawson kicks off to the Pit2. Chris Rainey return for 19 yards to Pit21. Tackled by Johnson Bademosi. | | |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Pit21 | Jonathan Dwyer rush to the right for 4 yards to the Pit25. Tackled by Sheldon Brown and Frostee Rucker. | | |
| Pit | 2nd&6 | Pit25 | Charlie Batch pass to the left to Jonathan Dwyer for 7 yards to the Pit32. Tackled by D'Qwell Jackson and T.J. Ward. | | |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Pit32 | Jonathan Dwyer rush to the right for 3 yards to the Pit35. Tackled by D'Qwell Jackson and Sheldon Brown. | | |
| Pit | 2nd&7 | Pit35 | Jonathan Dwyer rush to the left for 4 yards to the Pit39. Tackled by John Hughes. | | |
| Pit | 3rd&3 | Pit39 | Isaac Redman rush to the left for 2 yards to the Pit41. Tackled by Kaluka Maiava. | | |
| Pit | 4th&1 | Pit41 | Drew Butler punts for 41 yards to Cle18. No return. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Cle18 | Brandon Weeden pass to the middle to Benjamin Watson for 11 yards to the Cle29. Tackled by Larry Foote and Ryan Clark. | | |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Cle29 | Brandon Weeden pass to the left to Trent Richardson for 18 yards to the Cle47. Tackled by Ryan Clark. | | |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Cle47 | Trent Richardson rush to the left for 3 yards to the Cle50. Tackled by Casey Hampton. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&7 | Cle50 | Brandon Weeden incomplete pass to the right intended for Alex Smith. | | |
| Cle | 3rd&7 | Cle50 | Brandon Weeden incomplete pass to the right intended for Mohamed Massaquoi. | | |
| Cle | 4th&7 | Cle50 | Reggie Hodges punts for 30 yards to Pit20. No return. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Pit20 | Charlie Batch incomplete pass to the middle intended for Heath Miller. | | |
| Pit | 2nd&10 | Pit20 | Charlie Batch incomplete pass to the left intended for Will Johnson defensed by Usama Young. | | |
| Pit | 3rd&10 | Pit20 | Penalty: False Start on Pittsburgh (Emmanuel Sanders) -5 yards. | | |
| Pit | 3rd&15 | Pit15 | Charlie Batch pass to the right to Emmanuel Sanders for 11 yards to the Pit26. Tackled by Buster Skrine and D'Qwell Jackson. | | |
| Pit | 4th&4 | Pit26 | Drew Butler punts for 47 yards to Cle27. Joshua Cribbs return for 13 yards to Cle40. Tackled by Ryan Mundy. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Cle40 | Trent Richardson rush to the left for 4 yards to the Cle44. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&6 | Cle44 | Travis Benjamin rush to the left for 1 yard to the Cle45. Tackled by Keenan Lewis. | | |
| Cle | 3rd&5 | Cle45 | Brandon Weeden pass to the left to Benjamin Watson for 2 yards to the Cle47. | | |
| Cle | 4th&3 | Cle47 | Reggie Hodges punts for 39 yards to Pit14. No return. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Pit14 | Jonathan Dwyer rush to the right for 2 yards to the Pit16. Tackled by Jabaal Sheard. | | |
| |
| Second Quarter |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Pit | 2nd&8 | Pit16 | Penalty: Holding on Pittsburgh (Ramon Foster) -8 yards. | | |
| Pit | 2nd&16 | Pit8 | Jonathan Dwyer rush to the right for a loss of 3 yards to the Pit5. Tackled by Sheldon Brown. | | |
| Pit | 3rd&19 | Pit5 | Isaac Redman rush to the left for 5 yards to the Pit10. Tackled by Juqua Parker. FUMBLE, recovered by Cle (Buster Skrine). | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Pit10 | Trent Richardson rush to the left for 3 yards to the Pit7. Tackled by Lawrence Timmons and Ziggy Hood. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&7 | Pit7 | Trent Richardson rush to the right for 2 yards to the Pit5. Tackled by Jason Worilds. | | |
| Cle | 3rd&5 | Pit5 | Brandon Weeden pass to the right to Jordan Cameron for 5 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. | | |
| Cle | | | Phil Dawson extra point is good. | | |
| Cle | | | Drive Stats: 3 plays, 10 yards, 1min 21sec | 7 | 10 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Cle | | | Phil Dawson kicks off to the Pit0. Chris Rainey return for 25 yards to Pit18. Tackled by Trevin Wade. Penalty: Holding on Pittsburgh (Stevenson Sylvester) -9 yards. | | |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Pit9 | Charlie Batch pass to the left to Jonathan Dwyer for 2 yards to the Pit11. Tackled by Joe Haden. | | |
| Pit | 2nd&8 | Pit11 | Jonathan Dwyer rush to the left for 1 yard to the Pit12. Tackled by Jabaal Sheard. | | |
| Pit | 3rd&7 | Pit12 | Charlie Batch pass to the left to Emmanuel Sanders for 10 yards to the Pit22. Tackled by Sheldon Brown. | | |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Pit22 | Jonathan Dwyer rush to the right for 2 yards to the Pit24. Tackled by James-Michael Johnson. | | |
| Pit | 2nd&8 | Pit24 | Charlie Batch incomplete pass to the right intended for Heath Miller. | | |
| Pit | 3rd&8 | Pit24 | Charlie Batch incomplete pass to the left intended for Mike Wallace. | | |
| Pit | 4th&8 | Pit24 | Drew Butler punts for 50 yards to Cle26. Travis Benjamin return for 16 yards to Cle42. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Cle42 | Brandon Weeden pass to the left to Josh Gordon for 12 yards to the Pit46. Tackled by Keenan Lewis and Lawrence Timmons. | | |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Pit46 | Brandon Weeden rush to the right for 4 yards to the Pit42. Tackled by Will Allen. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&6 | Pit42 | Brandon Weeden pass to the left to Josh Gordon for 7 yards to the Pit35. Tackled by James Harrison. | | |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Pit35 | Trent Richardson rush to the right for 5 yards to the Pit30. Tackled by Ike Taylor. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&5 | Pit30 | Trent Richardson rush to the left for a loss of 3 yards to the Pit33. Tackled by Steve McLendon. | | |
| Cle | 3rd&8 | Pit33 | Brandon Weeden pass to the right to Benjamin Watson for 13 yards to the Pit20. Tackled by Lawrence Timmons. | | |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Pit20 | Trent Richardson rush to the right for 2 yards to the Pit18. Tackled by Larry Foote. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&8 | Pit18 | Trent Richardson rush to the right for no gain to the Pit18. Tackled by Cortez Allen. | | |
| Cle | 3rd&8 | Pit18 | Brandon Weeden rush to the right for 4 yards to the Pit14. Tackled by Lawrence Timmons. | | |
| Cle | 4th&4 | Pit14 | Phil Dawson 32 yard field goal attempt is GOOD. Holder: Reggie Hodges. | | |
| Cle | | | Drive Stats: 10 plays, 44 yards, 5min 34sec | 7 | 13 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Cle | | | Phil Dawson kicks off to the Pit11. Chris Rainey return for 15 yards to Pit26. Tackled by Tank Carder. | | |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Pit26 | Jonathan Dwyer rush to the right for 8 yards to the Pit34. Tackled by T.J. Ward. FUMBLE, recovered by Cle (D'Qwell Jackson). Tackled by Mike Adams. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Pit34 | Brandon Weeden sacked at Pit41 for a loss of 7 yards by Jason Worilds. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&17 | Pit41 | Trent Richardson rush to the left for no gain to the Pit41. Tackled by Ryan Clark. | | |
| Cle | 3rd&17 | Pit41 | Brandon Weeden incomplete pass to the right intended for Greg Little defensed by Ike Taylor. | | |
| Cle | 4th&17 | Pit41 | Two Minute Warning. | | |
| Cle | 4th&17 | Pit41 | Reggie Hodges punts for 25 yards to Pit16. No return. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Pit16 | Chris Rainey rush to the right for 6 yards to the Pit22. Tackled by D'Qwell Jackson. | | |
| Pit | 2nd&4 | Pit22 | Charlie Batch pass to the right to Emmanuel Sanders for 27 yards to the Pit49. Tackled by T.J. Ward. | | |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Pit49 | Pittsburgh Steelers timeout. | | |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Pit49 | Charlie Batch pass to the left to Chris Rainey for 4 yards to the Cle47. Tackled by Joe Haden. FUMBLE, recovered by Pit. | | |
| Pit | 2nd&6 | Cle47 | Charlie Batch pass to the right to Emmanuel Sanders for 10 yards to the Cle37. Tackled by Billy Winn. | | |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Cle37 | Charlie Batch incomplete pass to the right intended for David Gilreath. | | |
| Pit | 2nd&10 | Cle37 | Charlie Batch pass to the middle to Heath Miller for 11 yards to the Cle26. Tackled by Craig Robertson. | | |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Cle26 | Pittsburgh Steelers timeout. | | |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Cle26 | Charlie Batch incomplete pass to the right intended for Plaxico Burress. | | |
| Pit | 2nd&10 | Cle26 | Charlie Batch incomplete pass to the left intended for Mike Wallace. | | |
| Pit | 3rd&10 | Cle26 | Penalty: Pass Interference on Cleveland (Sheldon Brown) 25 yards. | | |
| Pit | 1st&1 | Cle1 | Chris Rainey rush to the left for 1 yard for a TOUCHDOWN. | | |
| Pit | | | Cleveland Browns timeout. | | |
| Pit | | | Shaun Suisham extra point is good. | | |
| Pit | | | Drive Stats: 9 plays, 84 yards, 1min 50sec | 14 | 13 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Pit | | | Shaun Suisham kicks off to the Cle42. Eric Hagg return for 5 yards to Cle47. Tackled by Ryan Mundy. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| |
| Third Quarter |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Cle | | | Phil Dawson kicks off to the Pit5. Chris Rainey return for 16 yards to Pit21. Tackled by Trevin Wade and Tank Carder. | | |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Pit21 | Penalty: Holding on Pittsburgh (Mike Adams) -10 yards. | | |
| Pit | 1st&20 | Pit11 | Penalty: Offside on Cleveland (Frostee Rucker) 5 yards. | | |
| Pit | 1st&15 | Pit16 | Charlie Batch pass to the right to Chris Rainey for a loss of 1 yard to the Pit15. Tackled by Craig Robertson. | | |
| Pit | 2nd&16 | Pit15 | Charlie Batch pass to the right to Heath Miller for 2 yards to the Pit17. Tackled by Buster Skrine. | | |
| Pit | 3rd&14 | Pit17 | Penalty: Delay of Game on Pittsburgh (Charlie Batch) -5 yards. | | |
| Pit | 3rd&19 | Pit12 | Charlie Batch pass to the left to Heath Miller for 9 yards to the Pit21. Tackled by Joe Haden and Buster Skrine. | | |
| Pit | 4th&10 | Pit21 | Drew Butler punts for 55 yards to Cle24. Joshua Cribbs - no return. Tackled by Curtis Brown and Cortez Allen. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Cle24 | Brandon Weeden pass to the right to Trent Richardson for 4 yards to the Cle28. Tackled by James Harrison. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&6 | Cle28 | Trent Richardson rush to the right for 4 yards to the Cle32. Tackled by Brett Keisel. | | |
| Cle | 3rd&2 | Cle32 | Brandon Weeden pass to the left to Mohamed Massaquoi for 4 yards to the Cle36. Tackled by Keenan Lewis. | | |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Cle36 | Trent Richardson rush to the right for 7 yards to the Cle43. Tackled by James Harrison and Larry Foote. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&3 | Cle43 | Trent Richardson rush to the left for a loss of 2 yards to the Cle41. Tackled by James Harrison. | | |
| Cle | 3rd&5 | Cle41 | Brandon Weeden incomplete pass to the right intended for Greg Little defensed by Ike Taylor. | | |
| Cle | 4th&5 | Cle41 | Reggie Hodges punts for 46 yards to Pit13. Emmanuel Sanders - no return. FUMBLE, recovered by Pit. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Pit15 | Chris Rainey rush to the right for 4 yards to the Pit19. Tackled by D'Qwell Jackson and Kaluka Maiava. | | |
| Pit | 2nd&6 | Pit19 | Charlie Batch incomplete pass to the middle intended for Mike Wallace defensed by T.J. Ward. | | |
| Pit | 3rd&6 | Pit19 | Charlie Batch pass intended for Plaxico Burress INTERCEPTED by Sheldon Brown and returned for 1 yard. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Pit31 | Brandon Weeden pass to the left to Trent Richardson for 4 yards to the Pit27. Tackled by Lawrence Timmons. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&6 | Pit27 | Brandon Weeden pass to the left to Mohamed Massaquoi for 17 yards to the Pit10. Tackled by Keenan Lewis. | | |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Pit10 | Penalty: False Start on Cleveland (Benjamin Watson) -5 yards. | | |
| Cle | 1st&15 | Pit15 | Trent Richardson rush to the left for 15 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. | | |
| Cle | | | Phil Dawson extra point is good. | | |
| Cle | | | Drive Stats: 3 plays, 31 yards, 1min 46sec | 14 | 20 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Cle | | | Phil Dawson kicks off to the Pit18. No return. | | |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Pit18 | Rashard Mendenhall rush to the left for 1 yard to the Pit19. Tackled by Frostee Rucker. | | |
| Pit | 2nd&9 | Pit19 | Charlie Batch pass to the middle to Heath Miller for 10 yards to the Pit29. Tackled by James-Michael Johnson and D'Qwell Jackson. | | |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Pit29 | Penalty: Holding on Pittsburgh (Heath Miller) -10 yards. | | |
| Pit | 1st&20 | Pit19 | Charlie Batch sacked at Pit13 for a loss of 6 yards by Phil Taylor. | | |
| Pit | 2nd&26 | Pit13 | Penalty: Holding on Pittsburgh (Kelvin Beachum) -6 yards. | | |
| Pit | 2nd&32 | Pit7 | Charlie Batch incomplete pass to the right intended for Emmanuel Sanders defensed by D'Qwell Jackson. | | |
| Pit | 3rd&32 | Pit7 | Charlie Batch pass to the left to Isaac Redman for 15 yards to the Pit22. Tackled by Eric Hagg. | | |
| Pit | 4th&17 | Pit22 | Drew Butler punts for 48 yards to Cle30. No return. Penalty: Holding on Cleveland (L.J. Fort) -10 yards. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Cle20 | Penalty: Holding on Cleveland (Shawn Lauvao) -10 yards. | | |
| Cle | 1st&20 | Cle10 | Trent Richardson rush to the right for 1 yard to the Cle11. Tackled by Ryan Clark. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&19 | Cle11 | Penalty: Holding on Cleveland (Shawn Lauvao) -5 yards. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&24 | Cle6 | Brandon Weeden pass to the right to Trent Richardson for 1 yard to the Cle7. Tackled by Lawrence Timmons. | | |
| |
| Fourth Quarter |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Cle | 3rd&23 | Cle7 | Brandon Weeden pass to the right to Greg Little for 6 yards to the Cle13. Tackled by James Harrison. | | |
| Cle | 4th&17 | Cle13 | Reggie Hodges punts for 39 yards to Pit48. Emmanuel Sanders return for 8 yards to Cle44. Tackled by Johnson Bademosi and L.J. Fort. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Cle44 | Rashard Mendenhall rush to the left for no gain to the Cle44. Tackled by Kaluka Maiava. FUMBLE, recovered by Pit (Will Johnson). | | |
| Pit | 2nd&9 | Cle43 | Charlie Batch pass to the left to Emmanuel Sanders for 15 yards to the Cle28. Tackled by D'Qwell Jackson. | | |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Cle28 | Jonathan Dwyer rush to the right for a loss of 2 yards to the Cle30. Tackled by Billy Winn. | | |
| Pit | 2nd&12 | Cle30 | Charlie Batch pass intended for Mike Wallace INTERCEPTED by Billy Winn defensed by Joe Haden. No return. Tackled by Doug Legursky. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Cle26 | Trent Richardson rush to the left for 1 yard to the Cle27. Tackled by Lawrence Timmons and Keenan Lewis. Penalty: Illegal Use of Hands on Pittsburgh (Casey Hampton) 5 yards. | | |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Cle32 | Trent Richardson rush to the right for 8 yards to the Cle40. Tackled by Larry Foote. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&2 | Cle40 | Penalty: Holding on Cleveland (Alex Mack) -10 yards. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&12 | Cle30 | Brandon Weeden sacked at Cle21 for a loss of 9 yards by Brett Keisel. | | |
| Cle | 3rd&21 | Cle21 | Trent Richardson rush to the left for 4 yards to the Cle25. Tackled by Lawrence Timmons. Penalty: Holding on Cleveland (John Greco) -10 yards. | | |
| Cle | 3rd&27 | Cle15 | Trent Richardson rush to the right for 4 yards to the Cle19. Tackled by Cortez Allen. | | |
| Cle | 4th&23 | Cle19 | Reggie Hodges punts for 46 yards to Pit35. No return. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Pit35 | Chris Rainey rush to the left for 7 yards to the Pit42. Tackled by Ahtyba Rubin. | | |
| Pit | 2nd&3 | Pit42 | Chris Rainey rush to the right for a loss of 1 yard to the Pit41. Tackled by James-Michael Johnson. | | |
| Pit | 3rd&4 | Pit41 | Charlie Batch incomplete pass to the left intended for Mike Wallace. | | |
| Pit | 4th&4 | Pit41 | Drew Butler punts for 34 yards to Cle25. Joshua Cribbs return for 14 yards to Cle39. Tackled by Cortez Allen. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Cle39 | Brandon Weeden sacked at Cle35 for a loss of 4 yards by Jason Worilds. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&14 | Cle35 | Brandon Weeden pass to the left to Josh Gordon for 15 yards to the Cle50. Tackled by Will Allen and Ryan Clark. | | |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Cle50 | Brandon Weeden pass to the left to Jordan Cameron for 7 yards to the Pit43. Tackled by Ryan Clark. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&3 | Pit43 | Trent Richardson rush to the right for a loss of 1 yard to the Pit44. Tackled by Brett Keisel and Ryan Clark. | | |
| Cle | 3rd&4 | Pit44 | Brandon Weeden incomplete pass to the left intended for Josh Gordon. | | |
| Cle | 4th&4 | Pit44 | Reggie Hodges punts for 29 yards to Pit15. No return. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Pit15 | Charlie Batch pass to the right to Heath Miller for 12 yards to the Pit27. Tackled by James-Michael Johnson. | | |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Pit27 | Charlie Batch pass to the right to Heath Miller for 19 yards to the Pit46. Tackled by Tashaun Gipson. | | |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Pit46 | Charlie Batch pass to the left to Chris Rainey for 1 yard to the Pit47. Tackled by D'Qwell Jackson and Kaluka Maiava. | | |
| Pit | 2nd&9 | Pit47 | Penalty: Holding on Pittsburgh (Doug Legursky) -10 yards. | | |
| Pit | 2nd&19 | Pit37 | Penalty: Illegal Use of Hands on Cleveland (Jabaal Sheard) 5 yards. | | |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Pit42 | Charlie Batch pass intended for Mike Wallace INTERCEPTED by Joe Haden. No return. Tackled by Mike Wallace. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Cle19 | Trent Richardson rush to the right for 2 yards to the Cle21. Tackled by Larry Foote. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&8 | Cle21 | Pittsburgh Steelers timeout. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&8 | Cle21 | Trent Richardson rush to the right for a loss of 2 yards to the Cle19. Tackled by James Harrison. | | |
| Cle | 3rd&10 | Cle19 | Pittsburgh Steelers timeout. | | |
| Cle | 3rd&10 | Cle19 | Trent Richardson rush to the left for 3 yards to the Cle22. Tackled by Jason Worilds. | | |
| Cle | 4th&7 | Cle22 | Pittsburgh Steelers timeout. | | |
| Cle | 4th&7 | Cle22 | Reggie Hodges punts for 49 yards to Pit29. Emmanuel Sanders return for a loss of 3 yards to Pit26. Tackled by Buster Skrine. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Pit26 | Charlie Batch pass to the middle to Chris Rainey for 11 yards to the Pit37. Tackled by D'Qwell Jackson. FUMBLE, recovered by Cle (Phil Taylor). Tackled by Ramon Foster. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Cle | 1st&10 | Pit40 | Trent Richardson rush to the right for a loss of 1 yard to the Pit41. Tackled by James Harrison. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&11 | Pit41 | Two Minute Warning. | | |
| Cle | 2nd&11 | Pit41 | Trent Richardson rush to the right for 5 yards to the Pit36. Tackled by Keenan Lewis. | | |
| Cle | 3rd&6 | Pit36 | Trent Richardson rush to the left for 3 yards to the Pit33. Tackled by James Harrison. | | |
| Cle | 4th&3 | Pit33 | Penalty: Delay of Game on Cleveland (Colt McCoy) -5 yards. | | |
| Cle | 4th&8 | Pit38 | Reggie Hodges punts for 35 yards to Pit3. No return. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Pit3 | Charlie Batch pass to the left to Will Johnson for 13 yards to the Pit16. Tackled by Tashaun Gipson. | | |
| Pit | 1st&10 | Pit16 | Charlie Batch incomplete pass to the left intended for Will Johnson. | | |
| Pit | 2nd&10 | Pit16 | Charlie Batch pass to the left to Mike Wallace for 9 yards to the Pit25. Lateral to Emmanuel Sanders for 2 yards to the Pit27. Tackled by T.J. Ward. FUMBLE, recovered by Cle (Craig Robertson) and returned for 2 yards. Tackled by Max Starks. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Pit | Cle |