| First Quarter |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Buf | | | Rian Lindell kicks off to the Ind3. Joe Lefeged return for 13 yards to Ind16. Tackled by Arthur Moats and Ron Brooks. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind16 | Penalty: Illegal Plyr Downfld on Indianapolis (Winston Justice) -5 yards. | | |
| Ind | 1st&15 | Ind11 | Andrew Luck pass to the left to Reggie Wayne for 4 yards to the Ind15. Tackled by Nick Barnett. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&11 | Ind15 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the left intended for Dwayne Allen. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&11 | Ind15 | Andrew Luck pass to the right to T.Y. Hilton for 18 yards to the Ind33. Tackled by Stephon Gilmore. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind33 | Vick Ballard rush to the left for 3 yards to the Ind36. Tackled by Leodis McKelvin. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&7 | Ind36 | Penalty: False Start on Indianapolis (Vick Ballard) -5 yards. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&12 | Ind31 | Vick Ballard rush up the middle for a loss of 1 yard to the Ind30. Tackled by Spencer Johnson and Nick Barnett. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&13 | Ind30 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the left intended for Dwayne Allen. | | |
| Ind | 4th&13 | Ind30 | Pat McAfee punts for 55 yards to Buf15. Leodis McKelvin return for 16 yards to Buf31. Tackled by Matt Overton and Delone Carter. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Buf31 | C.J. Spiller rush up the middle for 3 yards to the Buf34. Tackled by Fili Moala and Jerrell Freeman. | | |
| Buf | 2nd&7 | Buf34 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the left intended for Stevie Johnson defensed by Cassius Vaughn. | | |
| Buf | 3rd&7 | Buf34 | Ryan Fitzpatrick sacked at Buf27 for a loss of 7 yards by Jerrell Freeman. | | |
| Buf | 4th&14 | Buf27 | Shawn Powell punts for 48 yards to Ind25. T.Y. Hilton return for 75 yards to Buf0 for a TOUCHDOWN. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Ind | | | Adam Vinatieri extra point is good. | | |
| Ind | | | Drive Stats: 0 plays, 0 yards, 0sec | 0 | 7 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Ind | | | Pat McAfee kicks off to the Buf0. Touchback. | | |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Buf20 | C.J. Spiller rush to the left for a loss of 4 yards to the Buf16. Tackled by Jerrell Freeman and Robert Mathis. | | |
| Buf | 2nd&14 | Buf16 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the right to Stevie Johnson for 9 yards to the Buf25. Tackled by Moise Fokou. | | |
| Buf | 3rd&5 | Buf25 | Penalty: Offside on Indianapolis (Dwight Freeney) 5 yards. | | |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Buf30 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the right intended for Dorin Dickerson. | | |
| Buf | 2nd&10 | Buf30 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the right intended for C.J. Spiller. | | |
| Buf | 3rd&10 | Buf30 | Buffalo Bills timeout. | | |
| Buf | 3rd&10 | Buf30 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the left to T.J. Graham for 24 yards to the Ind46. Tackled by Darius Butler. | | |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Ind46 | C.J. Spiller rush up the middle for 3 yards to the Ind43. Tackled by Fili Moala and Cory Redding. | | |
| Buf | 2nd&7 | Ind43 | C.J. Spiller rush up the middle for 23 yards to the Ind20. Tackled by Antoine Bethea. | | |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Ind20 | C.J. Spiller rush up the middle for a loss of 1 yard to the Ind21. Tackled by Kavell Conner. | | |
| Buf | 2nd&11 | Ind21 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the left to T.J. Graham for no gain to the Ind21. Tackled by Cassius Vaughn. | | |
| Buf | 3rd&11 | Ind21 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the middle to Stevie Johnson for 6 yards to the Ind15. Tackled by Jerry Hughes and Jerrell Freeman. | | |
| Buf | 4th&5 | Ind15 | Rian Lindell 33 yard field goal attempt is GOOD. Holder: Shawn Powell. | | |
| Buf | | | Drive Stats: 11 plays, 65 yards, 5min 28sec | 3 | 7 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Buf | | | Rian Lindell kicks off to the Ind2. Joe Lefeged return for 18 yards to Ind20. Tackled by Justin Rogers. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind20 | Vick Ballard rush to the right for no gain to the Ind20. Tackled by Kyle Williams. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&10 | Ind20 | Vick Ballard rush up the middle for 11 yards to the Ind31. Tackled by Bryan Scott. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind31 | Andrew Luck pass to the right to Reggie Wayne for 7 yards to the Ind38. Tackled by Bryan Scott. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&3 | Ind38 | Vick Ballard rush to the right for 4 yards to the Ind42. Tackled by Bryan Scott. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind42 | Vick Ballard rush to the left for 9 yards to the Buf49. Tackled by Shawne Merriman. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&1 | Buf49 | Vick Ballard rush to the left for 2 yards to the Buf47. Tackled by Kelvin Sheppard. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Buf47 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the left intended for Donnie Avery. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&10 | Buf47 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the left intended for Donnie Avery defensed by Mario Williams. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&10 | Buf47 | Andrew Luck sacked at Ind50 for a loss of 3 yards by Mario Williams. | | |
| Ind | 4th&13 | Ind50 | Pat McAfee punts for 49 yards to Buf1. No return. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Buf1 | Ryan Fitzpatrick rush up the middle for 2 yards to the Buf3. Tackled by Jerrell Freeman and Lawrence Guy. | | |
| |
| Second Quarter |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Buf | 2nd&8 | Buf3 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the left to Donald Jones for 9 yards to the Buf12. Tackled by Jerrell Freeman. | | |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Buf12 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the left intended for Donald Jones. | | |
| Buf | 2nd&10 | Buf12 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the right intended for Stevie Johnson. | | |
| Buf | 3rd&10 | Buf12 | Fred Jackson rush to the right for 4 yards to the Buf16. Tackled by Ricardo Mathews and Darius Butler. | | |
| Buf | 4th&6 | Buf16 | Shawn Powell punts for 55 yards to Ind29. T.Y. Hilton return for 18 yards to Ind47. Tackled by Nigel Bradham. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind47 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the right intended for Reggie Wayne defensed by Stephon Gilmore. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&10 | Ind47 | Andrew Luck pass intended for Reggie Wayne INTERCEPTED by Justin Rogers and returned for a loss of 1 yard. Tackled by Reggie Wayne. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Buf46 | C.J. Spiller rush up the middle for 11 yards to the Ind43. Tackled by Jerrell Freeman and Antoine Bethea. | | |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Ind43 | C.J. Spiller rush to the left for 13 yards to the Ind30. Tackled by Jerrell Freeman. | | |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Ind30 | C.J. Spiller rush up the middle for 3 yards to the Ind27. Tackled by Darius Butler and Fili Moala. | | |
| Buf | 2nd&7 | Ind27 | Fred Jackson rush up the middle for a loss of 3 yards to the Ind30. Tackled by Jerrell Freeman. | | |
| Buf | 3rd&10 | Ind30 | Ryan Fitzpatrick sacked at Ind34 for a loss of 4 yards by Robert Mathis. | | |
| Buf | 4th&14 | Ind34 | Shawn Powell punts for 23 yards to Ind11. No return. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind11 | Donald Brown rush to the right for 3 yards to the Ind14. Tackled by Jairus Byrd. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&7 | Ind14 | Andrew Luck pass to the left to Donnie Avery for 4 yards to the Ind18. Tackled by Stephon Gilmore. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&3 | Ind18 | Andrew Luck rush up the middle for 8 yards to the Ind26. Tackled by Kyle Moore. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind26 | Andrew Luck pass to the right to Donald Brown for 23 yards to the Ind49. Tackled by Da'Norris Searcy. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind49 | Andrew Luck pass to the left to Dwayne Allen for 24 yards to the Buf27. Tackled by Jairus Byrd. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Buf27 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the left intended for Weslye Saunders. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&10 | Buf27 | Donald Brown rush to the right for a loss of 1 yard to the Buf28. Tackled by Jairus Byrd. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&11 | Buf28 | Andrew Luck rush to the right for 14 yards to the Buf14. Tackled by Kyle Moore. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Buf14 | Donald Brown rush to the left for 4 yards to the Buf10. Tackled by Nigel Bradham. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&6 | Buf10 | Donald Brown rush to the left for 3 yards to the Buf7. Tackled by Leodis McKelvin. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&3 | Buf7 | Indianapolis Colts timeout. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&3 | Buf7 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the left intended for Vick Ballard. | | |
| Ind | 4th&3 | Buf7 | Adam Vinatieri 25 yard field goal attempt is GOOD. Holder: Pat McAfee. | | |
| Ind | | | Drive Stats: 12 plays, 82 yards, 6min 3sec | 3 | 10 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Ind | | | Pat McAfee kicks off to the Buf0. Touchback. | | |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Buf20 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the right to Stevie Johnson for 63 yards to the Ind17. Tackled by Darius Butler and Tom Zbikowski. | | |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Ind17 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the right intended for Stevie Johnson. | | |
| Buf | 2nd&10 | Ind17 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the left intended for Stevie Johnson defensed by Darius Butler. | | |
| Buf | 3rd&10 | Ind17 | Ryan Fitzpatrick rush up the middle for 4 yards to the Ind13. Tackled by Jerrell Freeman. | | |
| Buf | 4th&6 | Ind13 | Rian Lindell 31 yard field goal attempt is GOOD. Holder: Shawn Powell. | | |
| Buf | | | Drive Stats: 5 plays, 67 yards, 1min 52sec | 6 | 10 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Buf | | | Rian Lindell kicks off to the Ind0. Joe Lefeged return for 18 yards to Ind15. Tackled by Mana Silva. Penalty: Holding on Indianapolis (Josh Gordy) -7 yards. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind8 | Vick Ballard rush up the middle for no gain to the Ind8. Tackled by Marcell Dareus. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&10 | Ind8 | Two Minute Warning. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&10 | Ind8 | Andrew Luck pass to the middle to Dwayne Allen for 2 yards to the Ind10. Tackled by Marcell Dareus. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&8 | Ind10 | Buffalo Bills timeout. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&8 | Ind10 | Andrew Luck pass to the left to Reggie Wayne for 10 yards to the Ind20. Tackled by Justin Rogers. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind20 | Andrew Luck pass to the left to Donnie Avery for 17 yards to the Ind37. Tackled by Leodis McKelvin. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind37 | Andrew Luck pass to the right to Dwayne Allen for 10 yards to the Ind47. Tackled by Bryan Scott. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind47 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the left intended for Reggie Wayne. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&10 | Ind47 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the left intended for Donnie Avery. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&10 | Ind47 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the right intended for Donnie Avery. | | |
| Ind | 4th&10 | Ind47 | Pat McAfee punts for 45 yards to Buf8. No return. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Buf8 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the right intended for Stevie Johnson. | | |
| Buf | 2nd&10 | Buf8 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the right intended for Stevie Johnson. | | |
| Buf | 3rd&10 | Buf8 | Fred Jackson rush up the middle for 4 yards to the Buf12. Tackled by Antonio Johnson and Robert Mathis. | | |
| Buf | 4th&6 | Buf12 | Indianapolis Colts timeout. | | |
| Buf | 4th&6 | Buf12 | Shawn Powell punts for 50 yards to Ind38. T.Y. Hilton return for 11 yards to Ind49. Tackled by Nigel Bradham. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind49 | Penalty: Pass Interference on Buffalo (Justin Rogers) 23 yards. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Buf28 | Andrew Luck pass to the left to Reggie Wayne for 25 yards to the Buf3. Tackled by Jairus Byrd. | | |
| Ind | 1st&3 | Buf3 | Indianapolis Colts timeout. | | |
| Ind | 1st&3 | Buf3 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the middle intended for Dwayne Allen defensed by Bryan Scott. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&3 | Buf3 | Andrew Luck pass to the right to Reggie Wayne for 2 yards to the Buf1. Tackled by Stephon Gilmore. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&1 | Buf1 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the middle. | | |
| Ind | 4th&1 | Buf1 | Adam Vinatieri 19 yard field goal attempt is GOOD. Holder: Pat McAfee. | | |
| Ind | | | Drive Stats: 5 plays, 50 yards, 32sec | 6 | 13 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| |
| Third Quarter |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Ind | | | Pat McAfee kicks off to the Buf0. Brad Smith return for 32 yards to Buf32. Tackled by Moise Fokou. | | |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Buf32 | Penalty: Holding on Indianapolis (Antonio Johnson) 5 yards. | | |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Buf37 | C.J. Spiller rush up the middle for no gain to the Buf37. Tackled by Cory Redding and Fili Moala. | | |
| Buf | 2nd&10 | Buf37 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the left intended for T.J. Graham. | | |
| Buf | 3rd&10 | Buf37 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the right to Scott Chandler for 10 yards to the Buf47. Tackled by Antoine Bethea. | | |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Buf47 | C.J. Spiller rush to the right for 5 yards to the Ind48. Tackled by Antoine Bethea. | | |
| Buf | 2nd&5 | Ind48 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the middle intended for Scott Chandler defensed by Fili Moala. | | |
| Buf | 3rd&5 | Ind48 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the middle intended for Stevie Johnson defensed by Moise Fokou. | | |
| Buf | 4th&5 | Ind48 | Shawn Powell punts for 35 yards to Ind13. No return. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind13 | Vick Ballard rush to the left for 9 yards to the Ind22. Tackled by Stephon Gilmore and George Wilson. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&1 | Ind22 | Vick Ballard rush up the middle for 3 yards to the Ind25. Tackled by Nick Barnett and Kelvin Sheppard. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind25 | Andrew Luck pass to the right to Weslye Saunders for 4 yards to the Ind29. Tackled by Nigel Bradham. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&6 | Ind29 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the right intended for Donnie Avery. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&6 | Ind29 | Andrew Luck pass to the left to Reggie Wayne for 15 yards to the Ind44. Tackled by George Wilson. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind44 | Vick Ballard rush to the left for a loss of 7 yards to the Ind37. Tackled by Nick Barnett. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&17 | Ind37 | Andrew Luck pass to the right to LaVon Brazill for 11 yards to the Ind48. Tackled by George Wilson. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&6 | Ind48 | Andrew Luck pass to the middle to Donnie Avery for 10 yards to the Buf42. Tackled by Stephon Gilmore. FUMBLE, recovered by Ind (Dwayne Allen). | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Buf42 | Penalty: Offside on Buffalo (Kyle Moore) 5 yards. | | |
| Ind | 1st&5 | Buf34 | Vick Ballard rush to the left for 9 yards to the Buf25. Tackled by Nick Barnett. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Buf25 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the middle intended for Reggie Wayne defensed by Stephon Gilmore. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&10 | Buf25 | Andrew Luck sacked at Buf32 for a loss of 7 yards by Marcell Dareus. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&17 | Buf32 | Andrew Luck pass to the left to Reggie Wayne for 25 yards to the Buf7. Tackled by Bryan Scott and Jairus Byrd. | | |
| Ind | 1st&7 | Buf7 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the left intended for Reggie Wayne. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&7 | Buf7 | Vick Ballard rush to the right for a loss of 1 yard to the Buf8. Tackled by Stephon Gilmore. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&8 | Buf8 | Andrew Luck pass to the middle to T.Y. Hilton for 8 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. | | |
| Ind | | | Adam Vinatieri extra point is good. | | |
| Ind | | | Drive Stats: 15 plays, 87 yards, 8min 4sec | 6 | 20 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Ind | | | Pat McAfee kicks off to the Buf0. Touchback. | | |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Buf20 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the left intended for Donald Jones. | | |
| Buf | 2nd&10 | Buf20 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the left intended for Stevie Johnson. | | |
| Buf | 3rd&10 | Buf20 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the left to Fred Jackson for 8 yards to the Buf28. Tackled by Jerrell Freeman. | | |
| Buf | 4th&2 | Buf28 | Shawn Powell punts for 57 yards to Ind15. T.Y. Hilton return for 7 yards to Ind22. Tackled by George Wilson. Penalty: Holding on Indianapolis (Cassius Vaughn) -10 yards. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind12 | Donald Brown rush up the middle for 1 yard to the Ind13. Tackled by Marcell Dareus. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&9 | Ind13 | Donald Brown rush to the left for 4 yards to the Ind17. Tackled by Jairus Byrd. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&5 | Ind17 | Andrew Luck sacked at Ind17 for no gain by Mario Williams. | | |
| Ind | 4th&5 | Ind17 | Pat McAfee punts for 59 yards to Buf24. Leodis McKelvin return for 8 yards to Buf32. Tackled by Jerry Hughes. Penalty: Illegal Block on Buffalo (Ron Brooks) -10 yards. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Buf22 | C.J. Spiller rush up the middle for 41 yards to the Ind37. Tackled by Antoine Bethea. | | |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Ind37 | C.J. Spiller rush up the middle for 6 yards to the Ind31. Tackled by Kavell Conner. | | |
| |
| Fourth Quarter |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Buf | 2nd&4 | Ind31 | C.J. Spiller rush to the left for 2 yards to the Ind29. Tackled by Moise Fokou. | | |
| Buf | 3rd&2 | Ind29 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the left to Stevie Johnson for 14 yards to the Ind15. Tackled by Tom Zbikowski. | | |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Ind15 | C.J. Spiller rush to the right for 2 yards to the Ind13. Tackled by Jerrell Freeman. | | |
| Buf | 2nd&8 | Ind13 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the middle to Donald Jones for 12 yards to the Ind1. Tackled by Tom Zbikowski. | | |
| Buf | 1st&1 | Ind1 | Fred Jackson rush up the middle for no gain to the Ind1. Tackled by Fili Moala and Kavell Conner. | | |
| Buf | 2nd&1 | Ind1 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the middle to Lee Smith for 1 yard for a TOUCHDOWN. | | |
| Buf | | | Rian Lindell extra point is good. | | |
| Buf | | | Drive Stats: 8 plays, 78 yards, 4min 36sec | 13 | 20 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Buf | | | Rian Lindell kicks off to the Ind5. Joe Lefeged return for 19 yards to Ind24. Tackled by Kelvin Sheppard. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind24 | Andrew Luck rush up the middle for 1 yard to the Ind25. Tackled by Marcell Dareus. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&9 | Ind25 | Andrew Luck pass to the middle to T.Y. Hilton for 7 yards to the Ind32. Tackled by Justin Rogers. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&2 | Ind32 | Andrew Luck sacked at Ind27 for a loss of 5 yards by Mario Williams. | | |
| Ind | 4th&7 | Ind27 | Pat McAfee punts for 54 yards to Buf19. Leodis McKelvin return for 10 yards to Buf29. Tackled by Matt Overton and Joe Lefeged. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Ind | 4th&7 | Ind27 | Pat McAfee punts for 48 yards to Buf25. No return. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Buf25 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the middle to Scott Chandler for 16 yards to the Buf41. Tackled by Antoine Bethea. | | |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Buf41 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the right to Donald Jones for 2 yards to the Buf43. Tackled by Josh Gordy. | | |
| Buf | 2nd&8 | Buf43 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the left to Stevie Johnson for 6 yards to the Buf49. Tackled by Jerrell Freeman. | | |
| Buf | 3rd&2 | Buf49 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the left to Stevie Johnson for 8 yards to the Ind43. Tackled by Cassius Vaughn. | | |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Ind43 | Fred Jackson rush to the left for 7 yards to the Ind36. Tackled by Jerrell Freeman and Martin Tevaseu. | | |
| Buf | 2nd&3 | Ind36 | Fred Jackson rush to the right for 4 yards to the Ind32. Tackled by Martin Tevaseu and Jerry Hughes. | | |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Ind32 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the left to Donald Jones for a loss of 4 yards to the Ind36. Tackled by Tom Zbikowski and Jerrell Freeman. | | |
| Buf | 2nd&14 | Ind36 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass intended for Stevie Johnson INTERCEPTED by Tom Zbikowski and returned for 20 yards. Tackled by Stevie Johnson. FUMBLE, recovered by Buf (Stevie Johnson). Tackled by Tom Zbikowski. | | |
| Buf | 1st&10 | Buf47 | Ryan Fitzpatrick rush to the left for 6 yards to the Ind47. | | |
| Buf | 2nd&4 | Ind47 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the left to C.J. Spiller for a loss of 4 yards to the Buf49. Tackled by Jerrell Freeman. | | |
| Buf | 3rd&8 | Buf49 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the left intended for C.J. Spiller defensed by Cassius Vaughn. | | |
| Buf | 4th&8 | Buf49 | Shawn Powell punts for 46 yards to Ind5. No return. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | Buf | Ind |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind5 | Andrew Luck incomplete pass to the right intended for Reggie Wayne defensed by Nick Barnett. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&10 | Ind5 | Donald Brown rush to the left for 11 yards to the Ind16. Tackled by Nigel Bradham and Da'Norris Searcy. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind16 | Donald Brown rush up the middle for 1 yard to the Ind17. Tackled by Nigel Bradham and Da'Norris Searcy. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&9 | Ind17 | Buffalo Bills timeout. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&9 | Ind17 | Andrew Luck pass to the left to Reggie Wayne for 14 yards to the Ind31. Tackled by Leodis McKelvin. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind31 | Two Minute Warning. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind31 | Donald Brown rush to the left for a loss of 1 yard to the Ind30. Tackled by Justin Rogers and Da'Norris Searcy. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&11 | Ind30 | Buffalo Bills timeout. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&11 | Ind30 | Donald Brown rush up the middle for 1 yard to the Ind31. Tackled by Kyle Williams and Nigel Bradham. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&10 | Ind31 | Buffalo Bills timeout. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&10 | Ind31 | Penalty: Pass Interference on Buffalo (Stephon Gilmore) 8 yards. | | |
| Ind | 1st&10 | Ind39 | Andrew Luck rush up the middle for a loss of 1 yard to the Ind38. | | |
| Ind | 2nd&11 | Ind38 | Andrew Luck rush up the middle for a loss of 1 yard to the Ind37. | | |
| Ind | 3rd&12 | Ind37 | Andrew Luck rush up the middle for a loss of 1 yard to the Ind36. | | |