New York |
| Goalkeepers | ||||||
| No. | Name | Position | Height | Weight | Birth Date | Birthplace |
| 24 | Santiago Castano | Goalkeeper | 1.88 m6-2 | 83 kg184 lbs | 4/14/1995 | Queens, New York |
| 1 | Kevin Hartman | Goalkeeper | 1.85 m6-1 | 89 kg196 lbs | 5/25/1974 | Athens, Ohio |
| 18 | Ryan Meara | Goalkeeper | 1.93 m6-4 | 84 kg185 lbs | 11/15/1990 | Yonkers, New York |
| 31 | Luis Robles | Goalkeeper | 1.85 m6-1 | 86 kg190 lbs | 5/11/1984 | Fort Huachuca, Arizona |
| Defenders | ||||||
| No. | Name | Position | Height | Weight | Birth Date | Birthplace |
| 25 | Brandon Barklage | Defender | 1.80 m5-11 | 79 kg175 lbs | 11/2/1986 | St. Louis, Missouri |
| 6 | Digao | Defender | 1.93 m6-4 | 83 kg183 lbs | 8/14/1985 | Brasilia, Brazil |
| 5 | Markus Holgersson | Defender | 1.88 m6-2 | 79 kg174 lbs | 4/16/1985 | Heisingborg, Sweden |
| 27 | Kosuke Kimura | Defender | 1.75 m5-9 | 69 kg153 lbs | 5/14/1984 | Kobe, Japan |
| 16 | Connor Lade | Defender | 1.68 m5-6 | 66 kg146 lbs | 11/16/1989 | Livingston, New Jersey |
| 7 | Roy Miller | Defender | 1.88 m6-2 | 77 kg170 lbs | 11/24/1989 | San Jose, Costa Rica |
| 4 | Jamison Olave | Defender | 1.85 m6-1 | 90 kg198 lbs | 4/21/1981 | Medellín, Colombia |
| 3 | Heath Pearce | Defender | 1.78 m5-10 | 79 kg175 lbs | 8/13/1984 | Modesto, California |
| Midfielders | ||||||
| No. | Name | Position | Height | Weight | Birth Date | Birthplace |
| 12 | Eric Alexander | Midfielder | 1.85 m6-1 | 75 kg165 lbs | 4/14/1988 | Portage, Michigan |
| 23 | Michael Bustamante | Midfielder | 1.75 m5-9 | 73 kg160 lbs | 9/21/1989 | Medellin, Colombia |
| 17 | Tim Cahill | Midfielder | 1.78 m5-10 | 75 kg165 lbs | 12/6/1979 | Sydney, Australia |
| 2 | Ian Christianson | Midfielder | 1.80 m5-11 | 70 kg155 lbs | 3/6/1991 | Cedar Rapids, Iowa |
| 8 | Juninho | Midfielder | 1.78 m5-10 | 71 kg156 lbs | 1/30/1975 | Recife, Brazil |
| 11 | Dax McCarty | Midfielder | 1.75 m5-9 | 68 kg150 lbs | 4/30/1987 | Winter Park, Florida |
| 13 | Marius Obekop | Midfielder | 5-10 | 168 lbs | 12/19/1994 | Yaounde, Cameroon |
| 10 | Lloyd Sam | Midfielder | 1.73 m5-8 | 74 kg163 lbs | 9/27/1984 | Leeds, England |
| 22 | Jonny Steele | Midfielder | 1.83 m6-0 | 82 kg180 lbs | 2/7/1986 | Larne, Northern Ireland |
| Forwards | ||||||
| No. | Name | Position | Height | Weight | Birth Date | Birthplace |
| 15 | Andre Akpan | Forward | 1.85 m6-1 | 86 kg190 lbs | 12/9/1987 | Grand Prarie, Texas |
| 21 | Ruben Bover | Forward | 1.70 m5-7 | 65 kg144 lbs | 6/24/1992 | Mallorca, Spain |
| 9 | Fabian Espindola | Forward | 1.75 m5-9 | 73 kg160 lbs | 5/4/1985 | Merlo, Argentina |
| 14 | Thierry Henry | Forward | 1.88 m6-2 | 83 kg183 lbs | 8/17/1977 | Les Ulis, France |
| 88 | Peguy Luyindula | Forward | 1.78 m5-10 | 72 kg158 lbs | 5/25/1979 | Kinshasa, DR Congo |
| 19 | Amando Moreno | Forward | 1.70 m5-7 | 66 kg145 lbs | 9/10/1995 | Perth Amboy, New Jersey |
| 92 | Rafhinha | Forward | 5-10 | 155 lbs | 2/3/1992 | Marechal Candido Rondon, Brazil |